How Small Failures Become Fertile Ground
Created at: September 8, 2025
Rise from small failures as if from fertile soil. — Mary Oliver
The Metaphor of Fertile Soil
At the outset, Mary Oliver’s line invites us to reinterpret missteps not as barren patches but as compost. In soil, what decays is not merely lost; it is transformed into nutrients that make future growth possible. Likewise, small failures—missed attempts, false starts, awkward drafts—can be broken down into insight and technique. By rising from them, we draw nourishment from what seemed useless, converting disappointment into the conditions for resilience.
Lessons From Ecology and Fire
Continuing the natural image, ecology shows that disturbance can spur renewal. Fire-adapted forests and prairies often rebound with greater diversity after carefully managed burns, while certain pine cones open only under heat, releasing seeds when the old canopy clears. Even volcanic ash, harsh at first, eventually enriches soils. These cycles suggest that set-backs, when bounded and understood, create space and nutrients for new beginnings. Thus, Oliver’s metaphor mirrors how living systems convert loss into life.
Iteration and the Power of Small Losses
Translating this to human endeavor, iterative practice turns small failures into information. Designers and inventors build rough prototypes, learn quickly, and adjust; James Dyson famously tested over 5,000 prototypes before a workable cyclone vacuum emerged. In the workplace, Kaizen and Agile sprints institutionalize brief, reversible experiments, so errors remain edible—easy to digest and learn from. In this way, each modest setback feeds the next attempt, much like compost enriches the next season’s growth.
Mary Oliver’s Practice of Attention
In Oliver’s poems, careful attention is the alchemy that turns pain into meaning. Her line, “Instructions for living a life: Pay attention. Be astonished. Tell about it,” from Sometimes, outlines a method: witness what happens, let wonder in, then articulate. Even sorrow becomes usable material; “Someone I loved once gave me a box full of darkness. It took me years to understand that this, too, was a gift,” she writes in The Uses of Sorrow. Through attention, darkness is sifted into fertile ground.
Turning Setbacks Into Compost
Practically speaking, we compost failure by processing it. After-action reviews—adapted from U.S. Army practice—ask three simple questions: What did we intend? What happened? What will we change next time? Coupled with reflective journaling and brief postmortems, these rituals extract nutrients from the experience. Moreover, a growth mindset (Carol Dweck, Mindset, 2006) frames ability as developing rather than fixed, encouraging us to treat errors as raw material rather than verdicts. Thus, learning becomes a soil-making habit.
Keeping Failures Small and Safe
Finally, not all failure is fertile; scale and safety matter. Psychological safety allows teams to speak candidly about mistakes without fear (Amy Edmondson, 1999), ensuring the compost pile gets built instead of hidden. Techniques like premortems (Gary Klein, 2007) and safe-to-fail experiments encourage bounded trials whose downsides are limited while the learning is rich. By designing for small, recoverable losses, we honor Oliver’s counsel: rise again, nourished by what went wrong, ready to grow.