There are years that ask questions and years that answer. — Zora Neale Hurston
—What lingers after this line?
One-minute reflection
What does this quote ask you to notice today?
A Calendar With a Personality
Zora Neale Hurston’s line treats time as something more intimate than a sequence of dates: some years interrogate us, and others respond. In that sense, a “questioning” year is not simply difficult, but actively formative—forcing choices, exposing gaps in certainty, and demanding that we define what we value. Conversely, an “answering” year isn’t necessarily easy; it is clarifying, when consequences arrive and patterns finally make sense. From the start, Hurston reframes the passage of time as a dialogue between lived experience and understanding.
The Seasons of Uncertainty
To see how a year can “ask,” think of periods when life becomes all provisional: a move, an illness, a breakup, a new job, a political upheaval. In such years, even routine decisions—where to live, whom to trust, what to pursue—feel like open-ended prompts. This is why the question is often not intellectual but existential: Who am I now, given what has changed? As Hurston implies, the point of the asking is not immediate resolution, but pressure that shapes the self through repeated, sometimes uncomfortable inquiry.
How Answers Actually Arrive
Yet answers rarely come as a single revelation; they accumulate through evidence, repetition, and aftermath. A year “answers” when the results of earlier risks become visible, when grief softens into memory, or when a hard-won skill finally feels natural. In that way, an answering year can be quiet: you notice you’re no longer bracing for impact, or you realize you’ve stopped negotiating with a reality you can’t change. This shift echoes the spirit of Viktor Frankl’s Man’s Search for Meaning (1946), where meaning emerges not from instant certainty but from enduring a process until a clearer stance becomes possible.
Questions and Answers as a Life Rhythm
Importantly, Hurston’s phrasing suggests alternation rather than a permanent state: the asking and answering are phases, not verdicts. That rhythm aligns with older reflections on time and transformation, such as Ecclesiastes 3 (“a time to…,” traditionally dated to the 3rd century BC), which portrays life as a sequence of fitting seasons rather than a linear climb toward closure. Once we accept that rhythm, the presence of unanswered questions becomes less like failure and more like a normal part of the cycle that precedes understanding.
Why the Questions Matter More Than We Admit
Moreover, questioning years often do essential work that can’t be skipped. They reveal what we’ve been avoiding, or what we’ve been living on borrowed assumptions. A common anecdote is the “career-question” year: someone feels restless, tries one brave experiment—taking a class, changing teams, volunteering—and discovers not an instant solution but a sharper set of preferences. The year asks, and the person answers not with a single plan, but with a new capacity to choose. In this way, the question itself becomes a tool that refines perception.
Living So the Answers Can Find You
Finally, Hurston’s insight carries a practical invitation: if some years answer, we should make ourselves available to hear them. That means keeping records, noticing patterns, and leaving room for reflection so that hindsight can do its work—whether through journaling, therapy, prayer, or long conversations with trusted friends. At the same time, it means acting during questioning years, because answers often depend on motion. Over time, the dialogue Hurston describes becomes a kind of wisdom: not the end of uncertainty, but the confidence that time can transform confusion into clarity.